Evaluation of Economic and Physical Policies for the Regeneration of Dilapidated and Historical Fabrics in Gorgan city

Document Type : Articles extracted from Thesis

Authors

Department of Geography, Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences, University of Golestan, Gorgan, Iran

Abstract

Extended Abstract
Introduction
Uncontrolled urban growth, socio-economic transformations, and rapid technological developments have led to the deterioration and functional decline of many historic urban fabrics that once served as key economic and social centers. This phenomenon not only reduces the quality of life for residents in these areas but also gradually undermines their historical and cultural value. In Iran, this issue holds particular significance. Deteriorated and historic urban fabrics in many cities across the country have progressively faced a range of challenges, including insufficient urban services, physical disorganization, economic decline, and the degradation of social environments. Historic cities such as Isfahan, Shiraz, and Gorgan, which possess rich architectural and cultural heritage, are now grappling with the problem of urban decay. Urban regeneration policies in Iran aim to preserve these historic areas, revive their cultural and economic values, and enhance the quality of life for local residents. Gorgan, with its deep historical and cultural roots, is among the cities seriously affected by the deterioration of its historic urban fabric. Currently, more than 681 hectares of old, deteriorated, and disorganized urban areas in Gorgan have been identified as being under serious threat from both natural and human-induced hazards. In light of population growth and the city’s physical expansion over recent decades, the primary objective of this study is to evaluate and analyze the economic and physical policies for the regeneration of deteriorated and historic urban fabrics in the city of Gorgan.
 
Methodology
The present research is applied in terms of its objective and descriptive-analytical in terms of its nature and methodology. The required data were collected through both documentary-library studies and fieldwork methods, including observation and questionnaires. According to the most recent statistical data, the statistical population of this study includes 13,777 residents living in the historical neighborhoods of Gorgan. Based on Cochran’s formula, the sample size was determined to be 374 individuals. Skewness and kurtosis tests were used to examine the normality of the data. For data analysis, SPSS version 22 was employed. To test the research hypotheses, one-sample t-tests, Pearson correlation tests, and regression analysis were utilized.
 
Results and discussion
The results of the Pearson correlation test indicated a significant relationship between governmental support policies and the increased willingness of residents in deteriorated areas, as well as construction stakeholders (builders and developers), to participate in regeneration efforts. A significant correlation was also observed between incentive-based policies for reconstruction, rehabilitation, and renovation and the regeneration of deteriorated and inefficient urban fabrics. Furthermore, the results of the regression analysis confirmed the positive impact of incentive-based reconstruction and rehabilitation policies on the regeneration of deteriorated and historical urban areas in Gorgan. The one-sample t-test results regarding the assessment of regeneration indicators (physical and economic) from the perspective of residents living in the deteriorated fabric revealed that the indicators of "quantitative physical," "financial physical," "quantitative economic," "qualitative economic," and "financial economic" all scored below the hypothetical average, indicating an undesirable condition. Only the "qualitative physical" indicator was found to be at an acceptable and relatively favorable level.
In the analysis of the first research question—concerning the relationship between governmental support policies and the willingness of residents and developers to participate in the regeneration of deteriorated and historical neighborhoods in Gorgan—the results suggest that this willingness is rooted in the economic and cultural needs of these areas. Such policies, through the provision of financial facilities, tax exemptions, and infrastructure development, create the necessary incentives for participation in reconstruction and contribute to a sense of security and public trust. In general, governmental support policies have the potential to revitalize the old urban fabric of Gorgan, mitigate urban decay, and increase investment and participation.
Regarding the second research question, the policy of exchanging deteriorated properties for newly built homes or land in Gorgan increases residents’ motivation to participate in regeneration due to the promise of improved living conditions and enhanced economic value. This policy, by increasing investment security and urban welfare, helps preserve the cultural and historical identity of deteriorated areas and attracts greater resident participation. As for the third research question, incentive-based rehabilitation and renovation policies in Gorgan have led to increased participation from both residents and investors in the regeneration of deteriorated and historical urban areas. These policies foster regeneration by improving quality of life, increasing economic value, preserving cultural identity, and building public trust, thus creating the necessary motivation for active involvement in urban renewal efforts.
 
Conclusion
In general, the findings of this study suggest that the regeneration of deteriorated and historic urban fabrics in the city of Gorgan faces major challenges in physical, economic, and social dimensions. Despite the historical and cultural significance of these areas, their current condition—particularly in terms of infrastructure and services in the economic and physical domains—is inadequate, which hinders active resident participation in the regeneration process. To overcome these challenges, a comprehensive and integrated approach is essential to improve living conditions and enhance the quality of urban environments. Incentive-based rehabilitation and renovation policies, with a focus on improving quality of life, preserving historical identity, and increasing economic value, can play a crucial role in the regeneration of these urban fabrics. These policies can not only boost the motivation of residents and investors to engage in regeneration projects but also foster a sense of trust and social belonging, thereby enhancing safety and overall well-being in these areas. In this regard, the preservation of historical and cultural values is emphasized as a core pillar of urban regeneration, as these attributes not only help maintain urban identity but also have the potential to attract tourism and stimulate economic growth.
 
Funding
There is no funding support.
 
Authors’ Contribution
Authors contributed equally to the conceptualization and writing of the article. All of the authors approved thecontent of the manuscript and agreed on all aspects of the work declaration of competing interest none.
 
Conflict of Interest
Authors declared no conflict of interest.
 
Acknowledgments
We are grateful to all the scientific consultants of this paper.
A B S T R A C T
Inefficient urban fabrics not only reduce quality of life and increase vulnerability to natural disasters, but also necessitate reconstruction and regeneration policies for sustainable urban development and improved living conditions. Accordingly, the main objective of this study is to evaluate and analyze the economic and physical policies of regenerating deteriorated and historical fabrics in the city of Gorgan. In terms of purpose, this research is applied, and in terms of nature and method, it is descriptive-analytical. The statistical population consists of residents of the historical and deteriorated neighborhoods in central Gorgan, with a sample size of 374 people determined using Cochran’s formula. For data analysis, SPSS software and Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) were employed. Findings revealed that government support policies—such as financial facilities, tax exemptions, and supportive infrastructure—had a direct role in increasing the willingness of residents and investors to participate in the regeneration of Gorgan’s deteriorated fabrics. These policies, by reducing the economic risks of projects and enhancing investment security, strengthened participation incentives. In addition, property-based incentive policies, especially the scheme of exchanging deteriorated properties for new housing or land, had a significant impact on boosting residents’ motivation to participate and enhancing social sustainability. Regeneration projects in Gorgan have led to improvements in indicators and functional performance. Although these improvements have not completely resolved existing problems, they represent a significant step toward improving quality of life and achieving sustainable regeneration of deteriorated urban fabrics.
Extended Abstract
Introduction
Uncontrolled urban growth, socio-economic transformations, and rapid technological developments have led to the deterioration and functional decline of many historic urban fabrics that once served as key economic and social centers. This phenomenon not only reduces the quality of life for residents in these areas but also gradually undermines their historical and cultural value. In Iran, this issue holds particular significance. Deteriorated and historic urban fabrics in many cities across the country have progressively faced a range of challenges, including insufficient urban services, physical disorganization, economic decline, and the degradation of social environments. Historic cities such as Isfahan, Shiraz, and Gorgan, which possess rich architectural and cultural heritage, are now grappling with the problem of urban decay. Urban regeneration policies in Iran aim to preserve these historic areas, revive their cultural and economic values, and enhance the quality of life for local residents. Gorgan, with its deep historical and cultural roots, is among the cities seriously affected by the deterioration of its historic urban fabric. Currently, more than 681 hectares of old, deteriorated, and disorganized urban areas in Gorgan have been identified as being under serious threat from both natural and human-induced hazards. In light of population growth and the city’s physical expansion over recent decades, the primary objective of this study is to evaluate and analyze the economic and physical policies for the regeneration of deteriorated and historic urban fabrics in the city of Gorgan.
 
Methodology
The present research is applied in terms of its objective and descriptive-analytical in terms of its nature and methodology. The required data were collected through both documentary-library studies and fieldwork methods, including observation and questionnaires. According to the most recent statistical data, the statistical population of this study includes 13,777 residents living in the historical neighborhoods of Gorgan. Based on Cochran’s formula, the sample size was determined to be 374 individuals. Skewness and kurtosis tests were used to examine the normality of the data. For data analysis, SPSS version 22 was employed. To test the research hypotheses, one-sample t-tests, Pearson correlation tests, and regression analysis were utilized.
 
Results and discussion
The results of the Pearson correlation test indicated a significant relationship between governmental support policies and the increased willingness of residents in deteriorated areas, as well as construction stakeholders (builders and developers), to participate in regeneration efforts. A significant correlation was also observed between incentive-based policies for reconstruction, rehabilitation, and renovation and the regeneration of deteriorated and inefficient urban fabrics. Furthermore, the results of the regression analysis confirmed the positive impact of incentive-based reconstruction and rehabilitation policies on the regeneration of deteriorated and historical urban areas in Gorgan. The one-sample t-test results regarding the assessment of regeneration indicators (physical and economic) from the perspective of residents living in the deteriorated fabric revealed that the indicators of "quantitative physical," "financial physical," "quantitative economic," "qualitative economic," and "financial economic" all scored below the hypothetical average, indicating an undesirable condition. Only the "qualitative physical" indicator was found to be at an acceptable and relatively favorable level.
In the analysis of the first research question—concerning the relationship between governmental support policies and the willingness of residents and developers to participate in the regeneration of deteriorated and historical neighborhoods in Gorgan—the results suggest that this willingness is rooted in the economic and cultural needs of these areas. Such policies, through the provision of financial facilities, tax exemptions, and infrastructure development, create the necessary incentives for participation in reconstruction and contribute to a sense of security and public trust. In general, governmental support policies have the potential to revitalize the old urban fabric of Gorgan, mitigate urban decay, and increase investment and participation.
Regarding the second research question, the policy of exchanging deteriorated properties for newly built homes or land in Gorgan increases residents’ motivation to participate in regeneration due to the promise of improved living conditions and enhanced economic value. This policy, by increasing investment security and urban welfare, helps preserve the cultural and historical identity of deteriorated areas and attracts greater resident participation. As for the third research question, incentive-based rehabilitation and renovation policies in Gorgan have led to increased participation from both residents and investors in the regeneration of deteriorated and historical urban areas. These policies foster regeneration by improving quality of life, increasing economic value, preserving cultural identity, and building public trust, thus creating the necessary motivation for active involvement in urban renewal efforts.
 
Conclusion
In general, the findings of this study suggest that the regeneration of deteriorated and historic urban fabrics in the city of Gorgan faces major challenges in physical, economic, and social dimensions. Despite the historical and cultural significance of these areas, their current condition—particularly in terms of infrastructure and services in the economic and physical domains—is inadequate, which hinders active resident participation in the regeneration process. To overcome these challenges, a comprehensive and integrated approach is essential to improve living conditions and enhance the quality of urban environments. Incentive-based rehabilitation and renovation policies, with a focus on improving quality of life, preserving historical identity, and increasing economic value, can play a crucial role in the regeneration of these urban fabrics. These policies can not only boost the motivation of residents and investors to engage in regeneration projects but also foster a sense of trust and social belonging, thereby enhancing safety and overall well-being in these areas. In this regard, the preservation of historical and cultural values is emphasized as a core pillar of urban regeneration, as these attributes not only help maintain urban identity but also have the potential to attract tourism and stimulate economic growth.
 
Funding
There is no funding support.
 
Authors’ Contribution
Authors contributed equally to the conceptualization and writing of the article. All of the authors approved thecontent of the manuscript and agreed on all aspects of the work declaration of competing interest none.
 
Conflict of Interest
Authors declared no conflict of interest.
 
Acknowledgments
We are grateful to all the scientific consultants of this paper.

Keywords


  1. Alseragy, A., Elnokaly, A., & Abul-Ela, M. (2018), Heritage-led Urban Regeneration as a Catalyst for Sustainable Urban Development. First edition. University of catania.chapter 4.642p.
  2. Awad, J., & Jung, C. (2022). Extracting the Planning Elements for Sustainable Urban Regeneration in Dubai with AHP (Analytic Hierarchy Process). Sustainable cities and society, 76, 103496.‌ https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scs.2021.103496
  3. Cheng, S.M. (2023). Rust and Smoke: a Memoryscape for Industrial Heritage: a Dissertation Submitted in Partial. Fulfilment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Landscape Architecture at Lincoln University (Doctoral dissertation, lincoln university).‌
  4. Korkmaz, C., & Balaban, O. (2020). Sustainability of Urban Regeneration in Turkey: Assessing the Performance of the North Ankara Urban Regeneration Project. Habitat International, 95, 102081.‌ https://doi.org/10.1016/j.habitatint.2019.102081
  5. Sarvi, S., & Abdollazadeh-Taraf, A. (2021). Regenerating the spatial structure of traditional neighborhoods with an approach to revitalizing their framework: A case study of the Hokmabad neighborhood in Tabriz. Journal of Geography and Planning, 25(77), 170-149. https://doi.org/10.22034/gp.2021.40443.2640
  6. Wang, H., Zhao, Y., Gao, X., & Gao, B. (2021). Collaborative Decision-making for Urban Regeneration: a literature review and Bibliometric Analysis. Land Use Policy, 107, 105479.‌ https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2021.105479
  7. Abdollahzadeh-Taraf, A., & Sarvi, S. (2021). Spatial structure regeneration of traditional neighborhoods with an approach to revitalizing their skeleton: Case study of Hokmabad neighborhood, Tabriz. Geography and Planning Journal, 25(77), 149–170. doi: 10.22034/gp.2021.40443.2640 [In Persian].
  8. Ahadnezhadrooshti, M., Heidari, M. T., & Moharami, S. (2020). Social regeneration of the historical texture with an urban tourism approach: Case study of Zanjan city. Geography Quarterly (Regional Planning), 10(3), 947–960. Dor: 20.1001.1.22286462.1399.10.39.26.3 [In Persian].
  9. Ariankia, M. (2018). Assessing the influential components of sense of security and women's presence in urban spaces (Case study: Gorgan City Park). Zagros Outlook, 10(37), 29–48. [In Persian].
  10. Ariankia, M. (2023). Evaluation of the spatial distribution and design status of urban furniture in Gorgan city using GIS. Geography and Human Relations, 5(4), 281–304. https://dor:20.1001.1.26453851.1402.5.4.14.9 [In Persian].
  11. Bazi, K., Moamari, E., & Sayadsalar, Y. (2020). Prioritization of urban neighborhoods in terms of housing physical structure for urban regeneration: Case study of Gorgan city. Urban Structure and Function Studies Quarterly, 7(23), 131–150. doi: 10.22080/usfs.2020.15981.1746 [In Persian].
  12. Daryabari, S. J., Salimi-Yekta, P., & Seyed Alipour, S. Kh. (2019). Study of improvement and renovation of worn-out textures in District 12 of Tehran city with emphasis on the regeneration approach. New Perspectives in Human Geography Quarterly, 11(2), 149–161. Dor: 20.1001.1.66972251.1398.11.2.9.6 [In Persian].
  13. Delfannasab, M., Shamaei, A., & Fasihi, H. (2020). Urban regeneration approach to tourism development in Tajrish neighborhood. Geography (Regional Planning), 10(3), 877–894. Dor: 20.1001.1.22286462.1399.10.39.22.9 [In Persian].
  14. Ghasemi, E., & Harandizadeh, S. (2023). Culture-based regeneration in historical textures to create a network of creative tourism axes: Case study of Shahshahan neighborhood, Isfahan. Research in Urban Space and Place Studies, 7(3), 5–26. doi: 10.22034/jspr.2024.2036153.1071 [In Persian].
  15. Iraji, H., Pourahmad, A., & Monfared, B. (2023). Regeneration of the worn-out texture of Abadeh city with minimal intervention and preservation of the urban skeleton. Geography and Human Relations Quarterly, 6(3), 402–426. doi: 10.22034/gahr.2023.397092.1874 [In Persian].
  16. Joudaki, H., Nouri Kermani, A., & Keshavarz, N. (2023). A model for explaining the factors influencing the regeneration of old urban textures: Case study of Dezful city. Environmental Planning Quarterly, 60, 23–45. Dor:20.1001.1.2676783.1402.16.60.2.6 [In Persian].
  17. Karimian-Bastani, M., Mokhtari, A., & Hafez-Rezazadeh, M. (2022). Spatial analysis of neighborhood-based economic and social approaches in the regeneration of worn-out urban textures: Case study of Districts 4 and 5 in Zahedan. Geography and Regional Planning Quarterly, 12(3), 590–603. doi:10.22034/jgeoq.2022.334201.3616 [In Persian].
  18. Khakjasteh, S. (2019). Analysis of urban worn-out texture regeneration dimensions: Case study of Lashkarabad neighborhood in Ahvaz city (Master’s thesis, Golestan University). Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences. [In Persian].
  19. Khaksar, A., & Mahdavi, E. (2023). Regeneration of historical urban fabrics with an approach to enhancing urban livability. Journal of Eastern Art and Civilization, 11(42), 54–63. doi: 10.22034/jaco.2023.405597.1328 [In Persian].
  20. Marouf-Nejad, A. (2021). Analysis and ranking of worn-out and inefficient urban textures based on social indicators using MABAC technique: Case study of Ameri, Khezaliyeh, and Hasirabad neighborhoods in District 7 of Ahvaz metropolis. Geography and Planning Journal, 25(78), 323–343. doi: 10.22034/gp.2021.44455.2778 [In Persian].
  21. Mirhosseini, H., Heydarabadi, A., & Farzaneh, S. (2023). Investigating the role of social capital in citizens’ participation in the reconstruction of worn-out urban textures: Case study of Gorgan and Gonbad cities. Urban Research and Planning Quarterly, 14(55), 319–336. doi: 10.30495/jupm.2022.25094.4039 [In Persian].
  22. Mirkatouli, J., Ariankia, M., & Baddast, B. (2016). Assessment of the sustainability status of housing physical indicators to improve urban settlements development: Case study of Gorgan city. Urban Areas Studies Journal, 3(4), 125–146. [In Persian].
  23. Mofidi, M., Izadi, M. S., & Bahraini, S. H. (2014). Approaches and policies of urban renewal: From reconstruction to sustainable urban regeneration. Urban Studies Quarterly, (9), 17–30. [In Persian].
  24. Mokhtari, E., Mirgholami, M., & Nejad-Ebrahimi, A. (2023). Comparative study of economic activities in creative regeneration of neighborhood centers in historical textures. Sustainable Urban and Regional Development Studies, 4(3), 102–122. Dor: 20.1001.1.27830764.1402.4.3.7.6 [In Persian].
  25. Movahed, A. (2013). Reconstruction of historical textures for enhancing urban identity (Master’s thesis, Islamic Azad University, Sirjan Branch). [In Persian].
  26. Najafi, E., Beyranvandzadeh, M., & Shahinifar, M. (2022). The integrated urban policy-making model and its role in regenerating inefficient textures: Case study of Khorramabad city. Geographical Engineering of the Land Quarterly, 6(2), 397–410. Dor: 20.1001.1.25381490.1401.6.12.3.2 [In Persian].
  27. Nasiri-Hendehkhaleh, E., & Salarinia, M. (2017). Analysis of factors influencing the regeneration of worn-out urban textures: Case study of Neighborhood 20 in District 17, Tehran. Land Geography Quarterly, 14(55), 135–148. [In Persian].
  28. Pouriyamehr, R. (2021). Analysis and evaluation of worn-out and inefficient urban textures for urban regeneration: Case study of Khorramabad County using the SWOT model. Geography and Human Relations, 3(4), 570–584. doi: 10.22034/gahr.2021.286448.1559 [In Persian].
  29. Rajabi, A., Pouraghasi, M., Vadaei-Kheyri, R., & Rezvani, A. A. (2022). The role of development catalyst projects in improving the quality of urban spaces: District 12 of Tehran. Zagros Outlook Journal of Urban Geography and Planning, 14(52), 83–106. [In Persian].
  30. Sabzevari, M. S. (2023). Analysis of factors affecting the livability of worn-out urban textures: Case study of Gorgan city (Master’s thesis, Golestan University). Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences. [In Persian].
  31. Sarvi, S., & Abdollahzadeh-Taraf, A. (2021). Spatial structure regeneration of traditional neighborhoods through the revitalization of their skeleton: Case study of Hokmabad neighborhood, Tabriz. Geography and Planning Journal, 25(77), 149–170. doi: 10.22034/gp.2021.40443.2640 [In Persian].
  32. Shafi’i-Dastjerdi, M., & Moradian-Boroujeni, P. (2015). Modeling location selection methods in regeneration of worn-out urban neighborhoods: Case study of Zeinabiyeh area, Isfahan. Urban Economics and Management Quarterly, 3(12), 137–154. [In Persian].
  33. Shahriari, M. R. (2021). Assessing urban regeneration indicators and their impact on citizens' quality of life in Sharif Abad neighborhood. Geography and Human Relations Quarterly, 4(2), 336–356. Dor: 20.1001.1.22286462.1399.10.39.22.9 [In Persian].
  34. Shams, M., Sahandi, A., & Soleimani, A. (2022). Sustainable development management and planning of urban textures: Case study of Khorramdarreh city. Geography and Regional Planning Quarterly, 12(2), 495–516. [In Persian].
  35. Shirazi-Irani, Sh., & Ariankia, M. (2024). Spatial analysis of livability status in the three districts of Gorgan city based on physical-spatial indicators. Urban Sustainable Development Journal, 5(15), 21–40. doi: 10.22034/usd.2024.2012647.1138 [In Persian].
  36. Sobhani Nobakht, H., Hekmatnia, H., Fakhar Tazeh Yazdi, F., & Salmanzadeh, S. (2023). Evaluation of worn-out urban textures with an urban regeneration approach: Case study of Miandoab city. Human Geography Research Quarterly, 55(3), 115–138. doi: 10.22059/jhgr.2022.332976.1008401 [In Persian].
  37. Tavakkolan, A., Pouyan, S., & Kargar, B. (2022). Evaluating the effectiveness of sustainable urban regeneration programs on improving the quality of life in informal settlements: Case study of Rasht city. Human Settlements Planning Studies Quarterly, 17(2), 377–390. Dor:20.1001.1.25385968.1401.17.2.18.0 [In Persian].
  38. Tazikhelmski, I., & Jahani, R. (2016). Principles of designing flexible urban spaces with a crisis management approach: Case study of Gorgan’s worn-out fabric. Disaster Prevention and Management Knowledge Quarterly, 6(2), 97–107. [In Persian].
  39. Yazdani, S., Taghinejad, K., Sheikholeslami, A., & Malekhosseini, A. (2020). A futures studies approach to creative regeneration of historical textures in Gorgan city. Geography (Regional Planning), 10(3), 201–217. Dor: 20.1001.1.22286462.1399.10.39.42.9 [In Persian].
  40. Zanganeh Shahraki, S., Malekian Bahabadi, M., & Sadat Badiheyi, B. (2024). The experience of culture-based regeneration in Sang-e-Siah neighborhood: A model for historical texture revitalization. Human Settlements Planning Studies Quarterly, 19(3). doi: 10.71633/jshsp.2024.1032448 [In Persian].
  41. Zanganeh, A., Sharif-Jahed, Sh., Soleimani-Mehranjani, M., & Kamanroudi-Kojouri, M. (2022). Spatial integration in the regeneration of worn-out textures: Case study of Tehran. Geographical Spatial Planning Quarterly, 12(2), 1–16. doi: 10.30488/gps.2020.223657.3210 [In Persian].
  42. Zanganeh, M., Abouyesani, K., & Borzouei, M. (2024). Assessing the social capital of residents to realize the urban regeneration approach (Case Study: Neighborhood of Joghatai City). Geography and Urban Space Development11(1), 93-109. doi: 10.22067/jgusd.2023.75554.1175. [In Persian].
  43. Zangiabadi, A., Rezaei Talarpashti, F., & Nastaran, M. (2020). Analysis of factors influencing the revitalization of historical textures with a sustainable tourism development approach: Case study of Gorgan. Journal of Geography and Regional Development, 18(1), 1–22. doi: 10.22067/geography.v18i1.71423 [In Persian].
  44. Zarei, J., & Safaeipour, M. (2017). Neighborhood-based planning and sustainable regeneration of worn-out urban textures with emphasis on social capital: Case study of Jolan neighborhood, Hamedan. Spatial Geography Comfort Quarterly, 7(23), 135–150. [In Persian].
  45. Ziari, K., & Hamghadam, N. (2021). Analysis of sustainability levels in neighborhood development and planning theory: Case study of neighborhoods in District 3 of Gorgan city. Scientific Journal of Geography and Planning, 25(76), 141–158. doi: 10.22034/gp.2021.41057.2669 [In Persian].